‘Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice

  BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents

‘Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice

 

علي كفه و كفي في العدل سواء

‘Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice.

 

Another reports has the wording:

كفتي و كف علي في العدل سواء

My scale and ‘Ali’s scale are equal in justice.

 

This narration is mawdu’. Al Khatib documented it in Tarikh Baghdad[1]. Ahmed al Tammar is responsible. The hadith comes from another chain which is worthless. Qasim al Malti is the only narrator

 

Qasim al Malti

• He would fabricate hadith

 

His Sheikh is Abu Umayyah al Mukhtit

• Al Dhahabi stated, “He is neither reliable nor trustable.”[2]

 

Next⇒  ‘Ali holds that position to me like my head in my body

---

[1] Tarikh Baghdad vol. 5 pg. 37.

[2] Mizan al I’tidal vol. 1 pg. 290; Lisan al Mizan vol. 1 pg. 286; Silsilat al Ahadith al Da’ifah Hadith: 4897.

  BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents

‘Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice

 

علي كفه و كفي في العدل سواء

‘Ali: his scale and mines are equal in justice.

 

Another reports has the wording:

كفتي و كف علي في العدل سواء

My scale and ‘Ali’s scale are equal in justice.

 

This narration is mawdu’. Al Khatib documented it in Tarikh Baghdad[1]. Ahmed al Tammar is responsible. The hadith comes from another chain which is worthless. Qasim al Malti is the only narrator

 

Qasim al Malti

• He would fabricate hadith

 

His Sheikh is Abu Umayyah al Mukhtit

• Al Dhahabi stated, “He is neither reliable nor trustable.”[2]

 

Next⇒  ‘Ali holds that position to me like my head in my body

---

[1] Tarikh Baghdad vol. 5 pg. 37.

[2] Mizan al I’tidal vol. 1 pg. 290; Lisan al Mizan vol. 1 pg. 286; Silsilat al Ahadith al Da’ifah Hadith: 4897.