Fatimah bint al Asad gave birth to ‘Ali in the Ka’bah
August 21, 2018A monkey committed adultery so they stoned it
August 21, 2018BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents
Fatimah would visit her uncle Hamzah’s grave, pray and cry at his graveside
إن فاطمة كانت تزور قبر عمها حمزة فتصلي و تبكي عنده
Fatimah would visit her uncle Hamzah’s grave. She would pray and cry at his graveside.
This narration is extremely da’if. Al Hakim narrated it saying, “Its narrators are reliable to the last one.” However, al Dhahabi contradicts him twice saying, “Extremely munkar. Sulaiman ibn Dawood al Madani is in the isnad.”[1]
Al Bayhaqi has critiqued the narration with inqita’ (missing link in the chain) between ‘Ali ibn al Hussain and Fatimah radiya Llahu ‘anha. Al San’ani highlighted this.[2]
May Allah curse the liars! Jafar al Subhani al Rafidi has blatantly lied. He claims that al Dhahabi agreed with al Hakim in this hadith[3] whereas the former contested him twice regarding Sulaiman ibn Dawood al Madani.
Next⇒ A monkey committed adultery so they stoned it
[1] Al Mustadrak vol. 1 pg. 377; vol. 3 pg. 28.
[2] Al Sunan al Kubra vol. 4 pg. 78; Subul al Salam vol. 2 pg. 115.
[3] Buhuth fi al Tawhid wa al Shirk pg. 85.
BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents
Fatimah would visit her uncle Hamzah’s grave, pray and cry at his graveside
إن فاطمة كانت تزور قبر عمها حمزة فتصلي و تبكي عنده
Fatimah would visit her uncle Hamzah’s grave. She would pray and cry at his graveside.
This narration is extremely da’if. Al Hakim narrated it saying, “Its narrators are reliable to the last one.” However, al Dhahabi contradicts him twice saying, “Extremely munkar. Sulaiman ibn Dawood al Madani is in the isnad.”[1]
Al Bayhaqi has critiqued the narration with inqita’ (missing link in the chain) between ‘Ali ibn al Hussain and Fatimah radiya Llahu ‘anha. Al San’ani highlighted this.[2]
May Allah curse the liars! Jafar al Subhani al Rafidi has blatantly lied. He claims that al Dhahabi agreed with al Hakim in this hadith[3] whereas the former contested him twice regarding Sulaiman ibn Dawood al Madani.
Next⇒ A monkey committed adultery so they stoned it
[1] Al Mustadrak vol. 1 pg. 377; vol. 3 pg. 28.
[2] Al Sunan al Kubra vol. 4 pg. 78; Subul al Salam vol. 2 pg. 115.
[3] Buhuth fi al Tawhid wa al Shirk pg. 85.