Contradictions in Shia Writings – NEW UPLOAD!!!

Contradictions in Shia Writings

An academic study that highlighting the Imamiyyah Shia’s confusion in explaining why ‘Ali radiya Llahu ‘anhu did not use the sword to claim his right to the Caliphate.

By:

‘Abdul Malik ibn ‘Abdur Rahman al Shafi’i

Click one of the sections below:

Introduction

Preface

Reason One

Sayyidina ‘Ali Lacked Supporters and Helpers With Whom to Fight the Usurpers of the Caliphate

Reason Two

Believing Descendants Were in the Loins of the Alleged Usurpers, So He Refrained from Killing Them Until Those Descendants Were Born

Reason Three

Fear That the Alleged Usurpers Would Apostatise from Islam Altogether

Reason Four

Fear of Civil Strife and Division among the Muslims

An Explanation of the Contradiction and Inconsistency between the Four Reasons

Conclusion