‘Umar would seek protection from a dilemma which Abu al Hassan is not present to solve

Burial of Sayyidah Fatimah radiya Llahu ‘anha
March 5, 2019
When the Jews of Khaybar would fight the Ghatfan, they would supplicate: O Allah, we beseech You by the right of Muhammad the unlettered Nabi
March 6, 2019

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents

 ‘Umar would seek protection from a dilemma which Abu al Hassan is not present to solve

 

كان عمر يتعوذ من معضلة ليس لها أبا الحسن

‘Umar would seek protection from a dilemma which Abu al Hassan is not present to solve.

 

The narration is da’if. Muammal ibn Ismail is present.

 

Mu’ammal ibn Ismail Abi ‘Abdul Rahman al ‘Adawi al Basri

  • Abu Hatim says, “ Staunch on the Sunnah. Blunders profusely.”[1]
  • Al Bukhari comments, “Munkar al hadith (contradicts reliable narrators).”
  • Ibn Sa’d and al Daraqutni remarked, “Blunders profusely.”
  • Al Marwazi says, “When he is the sole narrator of a hadith, it is necessary that tawaqquf be observed and it be examined since he had weak memory, and made plenty mistakes.”[2]
  • Al Bukhari states, “Munkar al hadith (contradicts reliable narrators).”[3]
  • Hafiz says, “Truthful with weak memory.”[4]

 

Next⇒ When the Jews of Khaybar would fight the Ghatfan, they would supplicate: O Allah, we beseech You by the right of Muhammad the unlettered Nabi


[1] Al Kashif vol. 2 pg. 309 Biography: 5747.

[2] Mizan al I’tidal vol. 2 pg. 221; Tahdhib al Tahdhib vol. 10 pg. 381.

[3] Man Tukullima Fih vol. 1 pg. 183 Biography: 347.

[4] Taqrib al Tahdhib Biography: 7029.

Back to top