O ‘Aisha, leave my brother for he is the first to embrace Islam

O people, I wished that this man could have sufficed me in it, and not me
March 12, 2019
O enemy of Allah and enemy of His Book, you stole Allah’s wealth? (‘Umar told Abu Hurairah)
March 12, 2019

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents

O ‘Aisha, leave my brother for he is the first to embrace Islam

 

يا عائشة دعي أخي فأنه أول الناس إسلاما و آخر الناس بي عهدا عند الموت و أولى الناس بي يوم القيامة

O ‘Aisha, leave my brother for he is the first to embrace Islam, the last person with me at my death, and the first person to be with me on the day of Qiyamah

 

This narration is a criticism against Sayyidah ‘Aisha radiya Llahu ‘anha since it mentions that ‘Ali was put between ‘Aisha and Rasulullah salla Llahu ‘alayhi wa sallam so ‘Aisha told him:

أما وجدت لك مكانا أوسع لك من هذا

Did you not find any space spacious enough for yourself than here?

 

‘Abdul Salam ibn Salih Abu al Salt

  • Al Dhahabi says, “Its isnad is filled with darkness. ‘Abdul Salam ibn Salih Abu al Salt is accused.”[1]
  • Al Dhahabi mentions reproof befitting Abu al Salt.[2]
  • Al Haythami says, “‘Abdul Salam ibn Salih is present therein. He is da’if.”[3]
  • Hafiz says, “Al ‘Uqayli records him in al Du’afa’[4] and documents this hadith of his.”[5]

 

Next⇒ O enemy of Allah and enemy of His Book, you stole Allah’s wealth? (‘Umar told Abu Hurairah)


[1] Mizan al I’tidal vol. 6 pg. 556.

[2] Siyar A’lam al Nubala’ vol. 11 pg. 447.

[3] Majma’ al Zawa’id vol. 9 pg. 114.

[4] Al Du’afa’ vol. 4 pg. 166.

[5] Lisan al Mizan vol. 6 pg. 127.

Back to top