THE FABLE OF THE ATTACK ON FATIMAH AND HER MISCARRIAGE —AN ACADEMIC ANALYSIS— NEW UPLOAD!!!
Q & A: Shi’ism Today and Yesterday – NEW UPLOAD!!!
November 19, 2024Introduction
November 21, 2024
THE FABLE OF THE ATTACK ON FATIMAH AND HER MISCARRIAGE
—AN ACADEMIC ANALYSIS—
by: Saʿd ibn Rāshid al-Shanfā
Click one of the sections below:
The Myth of the Broken Rib and Clarification of the Dispute
The Status of the Broken Rib Issue between Belief and History
Implications of Believing in the Broken Rib Myth
- The claim that ‘Ali was coerced into pledging allegiance to Abu Bakr
- Accusing Abu Bakr and ‘Umar of enmity towards the Ahlul Bayt
- The claim of oppression of Fatimah and the Ahlul Bayt
Study of the Narrations on the Rib Fracture
Section 1 – Musnad Narrations
What is attributed to the Prophet salla Llahu ‘alayhi wa sallam
1. The narration from Kitab Sulaim ibn Qais
3. The Narration of Kamil al Ziyarat
What is attributed to Sayyidina ‘Ali
What is attributed to Sayyidina Salman
What was attributed to Sayyidina ‘Ammar ibn Yasir
What was Attributed to Sa’id ibn al Musayyab
What is Attributed to Sayyidina Jafar al Sadiq
1. The Narration of al Khusaybi (d. 358 AH)
2. Narration from Kamil al Ziyarat
3. Narration from Dala’il al Imamah
4. The Narration of Kanz al Fawa’id
Second 2 – Non-Musnad Narrations
What is attributed to the Prophet salla Llahu ‘alayhi wa sallam
What is Attributed to Sayyidina ‘Ali
What is Attributed to Sayyidah Fatimah
What is attributed to Sayyidina al Hassan ibn ‘Ali
What is attributed to Muhammad ibn ‘Ali al Baqir
What is Attributed to Jafar al Sadiq
What is Attributed to al Hassan al ‘Askari
Report on the Weakness of All Chains of Transmission for the Narrations on the Breaking of the Rib
The translation of the book is still ongoing, In Sha Allah, the book will be updated as soon as new content becomes available, the pdf. file too will be updated accordingly.