Ayat Bayyinat

Ayat-e Bayyinat is the scholastic masterpiece of former Shia scholar, Nawab Muhsin al Mulk Sayed Muhammad Mahdi Ali Khan. A former Mujtahid of the Shia, well-versed in Shia theology and acquainted with the ‘secrets of the house’, his work is a unique rebuttal on the Shia creed, which establishes the beliefs of the Ahlus Sunnah and exposes a number of glaring contradictions and inconsistencies prevalent in the Shia creed.


Download pdf

Click one of the sections below:


Chapter one: 

Molana Sayed Abu al Hassan ‘Ali al-Hussaini Nadwi’s Opinion Regarding the Book and the Author


Foreword and Biography of the Author



Rational proofs of the virtues of the Sahabah radiya Llahu `anhum

Reported Evidence Regarding the Virtues of the Sahabah

The Virtues of the Sahabah in the Torah and Injil

Verses of the Qur’an Complimenting the Sahabah

The Testimonies of the A’immah Regarding the Virtues of the Sahabah


Chapter Two:


The Shia Answer to Verses Extolling the Virtues of the Sahaba

Proofs Establishing That the Sahaba Were Not Munafiqin

Proof 1

Proof 2

Proof 3

Proof 4

Proof 5


The Second Answer the Shia Present to Verses Extolling the Sahaba’s Virtue

The Third Answer the Shia Present to Verses Extolling the Sahaba’s Virtue

Textual Evidence




Chapter Three:

Introduction to Fadak

Point 1

Point 2

Point 3

Point 4

Point 5

Appendix – Imamah


Chapter Four:

Discussion Concerning Fadak

A list of Shia books written on the Fadak issue in chronological order

Discussion regarding the Gifting of Fadak

The inconsistencies and contradictions of Shia narrations regarding Rasulullah salla Llahu ‘alayhi wa sallam gifting Fadak to Fatimah

A Detailed Examination of the verse ‘And give the relative his right’

Adversity in the Era of Nubuwwah

Was Fadak in Fatimah’s possession?

Shia narrations concerning the claim over Fadak being gifted

Back to top