A challenge to all Shi`i Scholars

Foreword
October 29, 2015
Mut`ah of the Ithna’ `Ashariyyah in light of Qur’an and Sunnah
October 29, 2015
Show all

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents

 

A challenge to all Shi‘i Scholars

 

Those ‘ulamaʼ of the Shia who regard Mut’ah as entirely permissible and a means of reward, should please answer the following:

  1. Name any of your twelve Imams who were born as a result of Mut’ah?
  2. Name any of your muhaddithin who were born as a result of Mut’ah?
  3. Name any of your of your mufassirin who were born as a result of Mut’ah?
  4. Name any individual from amongst your devoted Shia followers, who handed over his daughter to one who was overcome with lust for the purpose of Mut’ah?
  5. Name any Shia leader from Ismail Safawi until Khomeini and Rafsanjani, who was born as a result of Mut’ah?
  6. Name anyone from amongst the Shia authors, who was born as a result of Mut’ah?
  7. Name any person from amongst the Shia grammarians and poets, who was born as a result of Mut’ah?
  8. Since the Iranian revolution, was there any Ayatollah or Hujjat Allah, who took pride in being the child from Mut’ah?
 

If you are unable to name any such person from your twelve hundred years of history, then is it not sufficient enough to prove that Mut’ah is not permitted in the din of Islam and can never have been condoned under the high standards of Islamic scruples, which Islam encourages.

 

So let the intelligent one’s ponder deeply over these realities.

 

NEXT⇒ Foreword

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents

 

A challenge to all Shi‘i Scholars

 

Those ‘ulamaʼ of the Shia who regard Mut’ah as entirely permissible and a means of reward, should please answer the following:

  1. Name any of your twelve Imams who were born as a result of Mut’ah?
  2. Name any of your muhaddithin who were born as a result of Mut’ah?
  3. Name any of your of your mufassirin who were born as a result of Mut’ah?
  4. Name any individual from amongst your devoted Shia followers, who handed over his daughter to one who was overcome with lust for the purpose of Mut’ah?
  5. Name any Shia leader from Ismail Safawi until Khomeini and Rafsanjani, who was born as a result of Mut’ah?
  6. Name anyone from amongst the Shia authors, who was born as a result of Mut’ah?
  7. Name any person from amongst the Shia grammarians and poets, who was born as a result of Mut’ah?
  8. Since the Iranian revolution, was there any Ayatollah or Hujjat Allah, who took pride in being the child from Mut’ah?
 

If you are unable to name any such person from your twelve hundred years of history, then is it not sufficient enough to prove that Mut’ah is not permitted in the din of Islam and can never have been condoned under the high standards of Islamic scruples, which Islam encourages.

 

So let the intelligent one’s ponder deeply over these realities.

 

NEXT⇒ Foreword