Hadiyyatush Shia part 2

November 22, 2016

‘Ammar ‘Ali’s letter

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents ‘Ammar ‘Ali’s letter   Respected Mir sahib I have received your letter and read its contents. You have stated that you are not convinced about the Shia stance pertaining to the estate of Fadak being oppressively withheld from Sayyidah Fatimatuz Zahra radiya Llahu `anha. The actual reason for your misgivings is that you have not come into contact with a proficient scholar as yet. […]
November 22, 2016

Response to the Allegation that The Prophet Had Only One Daughter

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents   Response to the letter The above is a word-for-word reproduction of ‘Ammar ‘Ali’s letter. Now be prepared to deliberate on our response so that the reality of his letter may be exposed and the prudence and insight of Shia scholars may be uncovered. Whilst it seems to contain lengthy allegations and criticism, it is void of substance. It contains three or four objections […]
November 21, 2016

The nikah of Umm Kulthum bint ‘Ali radiya Llahu `anha

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents   The nikah of Umm Kulthum bint ‘Ali radiya Llahu `anha   The third issue in his letter pertains to the marriage of Umm Kulthum radiya Llahu `anha, who is the biological child of ‘Ali radiya Llahu `anhu and Fatimah radiya Llahu `anha. Consequently he states that she was married to Muhammad ibn Jafar al Tayyar radiya Llahu `anhu. Whilst this response is correct, […]
November 21, 2016

The Discussion relating to the Fadak Estate

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents   The Discussion relating to the Fadak Estate Al hamd li l-Lah, we have responded adequately to all the allegations of ‘Ammar ‘Ali. However, in response to his allegations and accusations regarding the Fadak Estate, we ought to have retaliated tit for tat, but it is not appropriate for us to stoop to such levels and utter that which intelligent and noble people would […]
November 21, 2016

‘Ammar ‘Ali – Evidence of Forgery and Fabrication

BACK⇒ Return to Table of contents   ‘Ammar ‘Ali – evidence of forgery and fabrication   As for a professional and academic review of this narration in order to determine its veracity, it will be discussed shortly. To begin with, there is no doubt about the falsity of this narration simply on account of the dubious ‘Ammar ‘Ali expressing that it is found in authentic Sunni traditions. What could discredit […]